Picture this: Your brand has an incredible story and solves a near-universal problem, but your internal team doesn’t have the reach to share it. You’d love to get your message out there, but you need someone to help jump-start the process.
That’s where influencer marketing comes in. Influencer marketing is user-generated content (UGC) taken to the next level. It’s one of the fastest ways to boost visibility, build trust, and spark authentic engagement. What’s more, it’s tailor-made to target a specific audience.
Knowing how to find influencers that move the needle isn’t as simple as picking someone with a massive following or a familiar face within your niche. The real value in influencer campaigns comes from partnering with creators who align with your company’s values; people who speak your customers’ language and have the kind of influence that leads to action, not just impressions.
Let’s break down what you should look for in an influencer, where to find them, and how to tell if someone’s the right fit.
Key Takeaways
- Finding the right influencer is about fit, not just follower count.
- Know your target audience, campaign goals, and budget before you start looking.
- Use an influencer persona to guide your search and filter out mismatches.
- Always research 10 times the number of influencers you plan to work with.
- Keep outreach short, clear, and personalized for better response rates.
Table of Contents
- Key Takeaways
- What Is an Influencer?
- Types of Influencers: Choosing the Best Fit for Your Brand
- Steps to Finding Influencers for Your Brand
- How to Find Influencers: Expert Tips
- Conclusion
What Is an Influencer?
An influencer is someone who has built a loyal audience and can shape how that audience thinks, feels, or acts, especially when it comes to buying decisions. They’re trusted voices in specific communities; beauty, fitness, tech, and finance are all common places you’ll find them.
But influencers aren’t just celebrities or viral vloggers. They can be niche content creators with small groups of highly engaged followers. What makes influencers unique is their ability to authentically connect with and influence their community.
Difference Between an Influencer and a Content Creator
Most people who make a living by creating videos, editing photos, or producing high-quality social content prefer to be called content creators, not influencers. That’s because their following is built on the strength of their content itself—not just their ability to influence others.
On the other hand, those who became popular through something else—like acting, music, sports, or comedy—and then started doing brand deals are typically referred to as influencers. They may post paid content, but they don’t usually identify as content creators because content production isn’t their main craft.
Types of Influencers: Choosing the Best Fit for Your Brand
Knowing how to find influencers for your brand is important, but it’s just as critical to understand the different types of personalities. We often group influencers by follower count and what they offer:
- Nano-influencers: (1K to 10K): Tight-knit audiences that are great for grassroots engagement
- Micro-influencers (10K to 100K): High trust and strong engagement rates
- Macro-influencers (100K to 1M): Broader reach that’s perfect for growing awareness
- Mega-influencers (1M+): Massive visibility and celebrity-level influence
Each type of influencer has its strengths. For example, micro-influencers often drive more authentic engagement, while macro- or mega-influencers work well for big splash campaigns. Choose based on your goals, not just the numbers.
Nano-influencer
Nano-influencers typically have between 1,000 and 10,000 followers. They’re everyday people with highly engaged, tightly knit communities. Think local fitness coaches or niche hobbyists on Instagram or TikTok. They’re an excellent fit for small businesses, local brands, or startups who want to tap into hyper-targeted audiences.
A post shared by ♾️ RAYA DIZE – wake up 🪽 (@rayadize)
Popular nano-influencers include:
Some pros of nano-influencers are that they offer high engagement rates and authentic relationships with their followers. They’re also cost-effective for smaller budgets. The downside, however, is that they offer limited reach, and their content quality can vary.
When working with a nano-influencer, focus on personalized outreach and long-term relationships. They often prefer product-for-post collaborations or small fees.
Micro-influencer
Micro-influencers fall in the 10,000- to 100,000-follower range. They’re often experts in their niche; tech reviewers, skincare gurus, finance mavens, or fitness experts are common examples.
A post shared by Haruki Anoku (@hr.8ruki)
Popular micro-influencers include:
While micro-influencers offer high engagement, strong audience trust, and more professional content, they do have some drawbacks. Their reach is still relatively limited, and they may require some negotiation for fees or contracts. In many cases, micro-influencers with 30,000 followers or more will typically start to seek direct compensation instead of product-for-post or affiliate-only campaigns.
The best way to work with micro-influencers is to provide detailed briefs and track past campaigns to ensure they’re a good fit. Review their content history for the past few months to identify sponsored content, partnerships, and collaborations. While you may not have access to detailed metrics, you can look at engagement and count the comments, likes, and shares.
Don’t forget to examine audience feedback and brand conflicts; you won’t want to partner with influencers whose followers don’t like sponsored content or who have recently worked with direct competitors.
You’ll likely want to partner with micro-influencers when promoting direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands, lifestyle companies, or growing e-commerce businesses that want ROI-friendly influencer marketing.
Macro-influencer
With macro-influencers, whose reach falls between 100,000 and 1 million followers, you can tap into much larger audiences. These are popular YouTubers, fashion bloggers, or even ex-reality TV personalities. They work well when promoting national brands, apps, or products launching at scale that need to build awareness quickly. Many macro-influencers do this full time and have managers or agents to help negotiate contracts.
A post shared by Neil Patel (@neilpatel)
Popular macro-influencers include:
They have a big reach, polished content, and often more campaign experience. However, those benefits come with higher costs and potentially lower engagement rates than smaller influencers.
Before shelling out for macro-influencer campaigns, ensure their audience aligns with your customer base. While many influencers don’t provide detailed metrics, you can use a sourcing tool to uncover as much data as possible before signing a contract.
Mega-influencer
When you need to make the biggest splash possible, a mega-influencer campaign can help. Mega-influencers have millions of followers and often celebrity-level reach. These are pro athletes or internet-famous creators like MrBeast—who we’ve worked with in the past—or Charli D’Amelio. National campaigns, big brands, or product launches that need mass appeal are a great fit.
Embed rich media: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DI7hV5KTIh6/?hl=en
Some of the most popular mega-influencer celebrities are:
Their massive reach and instant visibility can provide a strong brand lift and put your brand in front of millions, but they’re costly: in the five- or six-figure range. The engagement rates can be lower, too. Finally, they may not be seen as authentic unless the partnership is clearly aligned.
Leverage mega-influencers for large-scale awareness plays, not conversions. And always vet audience demographics before you invest.
Steps to Finding Influencers for Your Brand
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer for how to find influencers for your brand. The right match usually depends on your audience, goals, and the story you want to tell. Following a clear process will make all the difference.
The following steps can help you identify potential partners and choose those who add the most value to your campaign(s).
Define Your Target Audience
Before you reach out to any influencer, be crystal clear about who you’re trying to reach through them. That means defining your target audience. Don’t just focus on age or location; think about their interests, challenges, and buying behaviors. Audience personas, web analytics, and social insights can help map this out.
An influencer who resonates with your audience can drive real results. The wrong fit, though? That can lead to wasted spend and zero impact, even if the influencer has a huge following.
Determine Campaign Goals and Budget
With your audience locked in, figure out what success means. Are you aiming for brand awareness, product sales, email signups, or something else? Your goals will shape the kind of influencer you need (and how you’ll measure ROI).
Your budget is important here, too. Influencer rates vary widely based on several factors, like:
- Platform
- Content rights
- Follower count
- Engagement rate
- Saturation of brand deals
- Required competitor exclusivity
- Scope of engagement
Be realistic about what you can afford. Decide what your offer will include: cash, product swaps, or a little bit of both.
Create an Influencer Persona
Once you know who to talk to and what you want to achieve, it’s time to clarify who should be talking. An influencer persona is similar to a buyer persona, but for your ideal partner. This can narrow down your search and weed out wrong fits early.
Start with the basics:
- Follower count: Match to your goals and budget.
- Engagement rate: Smaller, highly engaged audiences usually trump massive, passive ones. Industry standards set 2 percent as a strong engagement rate.
- Content vertical: Do they post about topics related to your brand?
- Posting cadence: Are they consistent posters, or do they disappear for weeks?
- Location: Local businesses or region-specific campaigns require proximity.
Next, let’s look at qualitative factors:
- Authenticity: Does their content feel real or overly staged?
- Past brand partnerships: Have they worked with competitors? Do they work with everyone?
- Brand safety: What’s their reputation? Are there red flags in comments or press?
- Aesthetics and tone: Does their style match your brand’s voice and visual identity?
When you take the time to build this persona, outreach becomes easier. It also helps your team align before you pitch influencers or agencies.
Review Influencers to Find the Right Fit
With the influencer persona nailed down, the real work begins: finding people who match it. This step takes time, and many brands can get overwhelmed by it. Doing your homework on audience, goals, and ideal traits makes this easier.
When you look for influencers, avoid one critical mistake that kills campaigns before they get started: not vetting enough influencers.
Ideally, you should seek out at least 10 times the number of influencers you plan to work with. If you want one great fit, for example, start with at least 10 on your list. That gives you room to reach out, hear back, and choose the best option from the interest group.
Knowing how to find influencers for your brand involves looking in multiple spots. Consider the following tips:
- Use influencer-specific curation platforms. Search engines like Upfluence, CreatorIQ, and Captiv8, are the most commonly sourced avenues. TikTok Creator Marketplace also offers a great stepping stone for finding influencers.
- Search on social media platforms. Start with Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, and LinkedIn—basically, wherever your audience spends time. Use hashtags, location tags, or niche-specific terms to uncover potential matches.
- Use Google or other search engines. Try searches like “top food influencers in Chicago” or “best nano beauty influencers.” Roundup articles and blog posts often list relevant creators.
- Check out your competitors’ campaigns. Your competitors’ tagged posts or mentions can be a great resource for real-world examples of influencer-brand collaborations that performed well (or didn’t).
- Tap into agencies and influencer platforms. Skip the manual legwork and scale fast by partnering with an agency like NP Digital. We have access to databases of vetted influencers and can manage outreach, negotiations, and performance tracking.
- Explore niche communities, forums, and events. Look beyond social media to Reddit threads, Slack groups, Discord, and other communities. These creators may not have millions of followers, but they could be perfect for your campaign.
At this point, you should have a short list of influencers who meet your criteria. Reach out, pitch your campaign, and expect a drop-off in replies. That’s normal. It’s also why you need the 10x rule.
Plan ahead, be selective, and take your time vetting influencers. The right fit can make or break your campaign.
How to Find Influencers: Expert Tips
Knowing how to find influencers is half the battle. Reaching the right people is the next step, and many brands overthink it.
Influencers are busy. If your message is too long, vague, or generic, they’ll probably ignore you.
Be clear, concise, and direct. Here’s how to approach it like a professional:
- Keep outreach short and focused. Don’t use essays or five-page decks. Your first message should be under 150 words. Lead with who you are, why you’re reaching out, and what you offer. Personalize it to show that you’ve actually seen their content.
- Be transparent about what you want. Say the kind of content you’re looking for (like Instagram Reels, YouTube unboxing, or a TikTok review) and when you need it. The more upfront you are, the smoother the collaboration will be.
- Outline what you’re offering. Spell out what you plan to offer, whether that’s payment or products. Influencers want to know what’s in it for them before considering a partnership.
- Create a simple proposal. As part of your initial outreach, send a clear one-page brief that provides a campaign overview, deliverables, timeline, payment details, and guidelines. Skip the fluff and stick to what matters. Sending this eliminates unnecessary back-and-forth and shows you value the influencer’s time.
- Build the relationship. Once you’ve worked together, keep in touch. Like and comment on their posts. Send occasional updates or exclusive sneak peeks. Influencers are more likely to work with brands that treat them like partners, not just for one-time promotions. Be aware, however, that communication shouldn’t be one-sided. Just adding them to your marketing emails is a bad look; instead, curate communication and send tailored messages.
Great brand-influencer relationships can start when you respect their time and are clear about your expectations.
Conclusion
Finding the right influencer for your brand isn’t rocket science, but it does require more than just seeking someone with a high follower count.
Before you start searching, think about how influencer marketing fits into your overall portfolio and budget. Whether you want an influencer for B2B campaigns or as part of your “search everywhere” strategy, you should be mindful of what fits your brand.
Approach it like a relationship instead of a single campaign, and you’ll reap plenty of benefits.
See How My Agency Can Drive More Traffic to Your Website
- SEO - unlock more SEO traffic. See real results.
- Content Marketing - our team creates epic content that will get shared, get links, and attract traffic.
- Paid Media - effective paid strategies with clear ROI.
Are You Using Google Ads? Try Our FREE Ads Grader!
Stop wasting money and unlock the hidden potential of your advertising.
- Discover the power of intentional advertising.
- Reach your ideal target audience.
- Maximize ad spend efficiency.
