4 Landing Page Credibility Killers You Should Eliminate Right Now

Written by Neil Patel on March 19, 2016


It happens to us all.

Sometimes we fail to achieve our set goals, especially when it comes to generating and capturing leads. According to Econsultancy, “only about 22% of businesses are satisfied with their conversion rates.”

You’ve worked hard to build your landing page and it looks great. But, somehow, you’re not converting leads as you expected.

If you study several landing pages, you’ll notice that some of them don’t inspire you to take action. Worse, you even doubt the credibility of the marketer or owner. Whatever turned you off on that page is a credibility killer.

This cheat sheet will help you fix 4 landing page credibility killers.

When you’re building a landing page for the purpose of converting leads into customers, you must take bold steps to eliminate all potential credibility killers.

Landing pages, in general, are effective tools for building your business. According to MarketingSherpa, “landing pages are effective for 94% of B2B and B2C companies.”


In this in-depth article, I want to show you 4 landing page credibility killers that you should eliminate right now. Let’s go: 

1. Lack of Social Proof

Credibility is contextual. In other words, what I see as being credible may not mean anything to you. For me personally, copy with a big, bold, red headline seems spammy to me. I won’t click or take any other action.

Other people might love it.

However, social proof is an integral part of building the kind of credibility that most marketers want. A landing page that lacks social proof may convert fewer leads than one with social proof.

With social proof, you don’t need to explain that your product truly delivers results. It just shows. Of course, there’s nothing new about social proof and its use in landing pages, but how often do you use it?

The concept of social proof was popularized by Robert Cialdini in his book Influence. It’s based on a simple principle: we’re all more likely to do what we observe other people do. This principle relies primarily on numbers – the higher the number, the stronger the proof.

Do you remember the classic McDonald’s billboard ad? Obviously, if they’ve served billions of people, we would all believe that they truly know what they’re doing, right?


Would you want to eat in a restaurant that’s completely empty, or board a commercial airplane with no other passengers?

In the same way, nobody wants to take the first chance and lose money. If others aren’t doing it, then why would you want to be the first?

When potential customers don’t see any form of social proof, they’ve just confirmed for themselves that your offer probably isn’t as valuable as you’ve claimed.

That’s why integrating social proof into your landing page is crucial.

Let’s get practical now. If you’ve been featured on Huffington Post, Forbes, or the New York Times, or if you have renowned companies as clients, let the world know.

Remember to make your social proof visible. YouBars is one of the sites that understand the value of social proof. The site featured positive quotes from the NY Times and other popular publications.


Made.com, a company that sells custom made furniture direct from manufacturers, also uses social proof, displayed below-the-fold. Take a look:


There’s also such a thing as negative social proof. Negative proof sends a signal or message to your target audience that you’re lazy, dishonest, ineffective or all three.

For example, if you have a blog but haven’t updated it in the past 3 months (especially when the dates are displayed), then you’re leaving negative proof – you’re signaling that you’re unreliable.

Other forms of negative social proofs that you should remove include:

  • Social share counters that show nobody is sharing
  • A Facebook page with no new posts and fewer than 43 fans
  • Testimonials that sound too-good-to-be-true or fake
  • A product that’s too costly – or too cheap
  • Allowing spammy comments to stay in your comments feed

Remember that social proof comes in different forms. You may not have thousands of social shares like UpWorthy, but you should start with what you already have. Showcase the exact or estimated number of the customers and clients that you currently work with.

MailChimp does this well.


Or, you can show how many countries your products or services have reached and how many customers you currently have. See how GetResponse displays it right below the headline, above-the-fold?:


Last but not least, you can also use case studies to improve the credibility of your offers. People will feel more confident in your product or services, knowing that your offer will help them get results, too.

Through case studies and proven results you’ve generated for other brands, people can trust you more, because you’ve got results to show for it.

One authority site that does this well is Conversion-Rate-Experts.com. Beyond the usual case studies, they go further and compile the case studies into a downloadable ebook.


Note that there is also external social proof that isn’t quantifiable or seen by the customers.

For example, well-known brands like Amazon don’t need any on-site social proof to show that their products are of the highest quality. Amazon is already a household name, and people believe that they can trust it.

But as much as you can, use honest, trustworthy social proof to build credibility. Get rid of the negative social proof and watch your conversion rates soar.

2. Lack of Security/Social Symbols

Do you want your customers to feel secure?

I asked this question earlier, but it’s worth repeating. The truth is that if your customers don’t feel secure, they won’t respond to your offers, no matter how helpful you claim your product is.

Security and social symbols that can boost landing page credibility include:

  • Quality/money guarantees
  • Clear return/refund policies
  • Trust marks

An absence of these social symbols and security features on a landing page can actually lower conversions.

If you have a lesser known brand and you haven’t included one of those security features on your landing page, it’s going to be difficult to convince potential customers to buy from you.

Let’s assume that you sell clothing and shoes. Before customers place an order, they’ll be asking questions like “will it fit?” and “does the color look the same as it does in the picture?”

To give the customer a sense of safety when they’re spending their money on your items or services, clearly state your refund and return policies. Zappos has grown into a very successful shoe and accessory site, in part, because of their iron-clad “no questions asked” return policy.


Here’s what Craig Adkins, Zappo’s executive, has to say:

Our best customers have the highest returns rates, but they are also the ones that spend the most money with us and are our most profitable customers. Zappos’ modus operandi is not to give its purchasers the cheapest footwear on the block, but to give them the best service: hence, a 365-day returns policy, and free two-way shipping.

Zappos allows returns in a longer timeframe than the customer is probably used to enjoying. If you were personally shopping for a digital camera and were presented with two retailer return options, which would you choose?

Retailer A: “We accept free returns for 30 – 45 days after purchase.”

Retailer B: “We accept free returns within 6 months. Guaranteed.”

I would absolutely choose Retailer B, because the time frame for the return policy extends into 6 months, whereas Retailer A offers only four to six weeks with no guarantee. 

Ideally, you could allow your customers to buy your products on a trial basis. If you trust that your product will deliver and motivate people to stick with it, offering it on trial basis can help increase customer confidence.

Glasses Direct, a brand that sells eyeglasses, builds strong credibility with their customers, by giving them the opportunity to buy on a trial basis.


A money-back guarantee always reassures prospective customers about purchasing a product. After all, they have nothing to lose. If your product doesn’t deliver, they can get their money back.

Derek Halpern offers a money-back guarantee for his Zippy Course, and also guarantees that customers will be 100% satisfied.


All of these security measures will help increase the conversion rate on your landing page and boost your credibility. Without them, your credibility will be questionable and customers are much less likely to take the risk.

Before we close out this section, let’s quickly look at trust seals.

Trust seals are symbols that help reassure site visitors and customers (especially those who don’t trust the brand) that their personal information (e.g., email address, credit card details, phone number) is secure with the company they’re giving it to – assuming they’re completing a form on the site, responding to a survey, or filling out a questionnaire.

Some common trust seals are shown below:


When people come to your landing page, they may not understand textual security promises. Stating that their credit card information is secure only takes you so far.

You’ve got to add visual clues, such as colors, graphics and background colors, as well as visual seals, to your payment forms. This will instantly increase your copy’s credibility – because they prove security to your prospects & customers.

Trust seals are effective credibility boosters on your landing page. But, not all trust seals are created equal. Some are trusted more than others.

Baymard conducted a survey in 2013 to determine which trust seals are most trusted. The sample size was fairly large and Baymard received 2,510 responses. They tested up-to-date versions of 8 of the most popular site seals.

Out of these 2,510 responses, 35.6% of respondents trust Norton’s seal most of all, followed by McAfee.


So does the Norton seal work best?

Well, not necessarily. Every website and niche is different. A Norton seal may have worked better for these consumers, but others might prefer a BBB seal, since the BBB as an organization is focused on protecting the buyer.

The best way to know which trust seal is ideal for your landing page is to conduct an A/B split test. Then, you can be sure which seal reassures your specific prospects and customers most of all.

Do you have a privacy policy statement on your landing page? Sometimes people hesitate opting in to a newsletter or buying a product, unless you state that their personal data is safe & secure.

One or two sentences is all that you need when stating your privacy policy. I use a privacy policy currently on QuickSprout’s lead magnet page.


3. Poor Grammar and Misspelled Words

Your landing page copy doesn’t have to win a Pulitzer Prize award, but it should be structured properly. Good grammar and correct spelling are important for your credibility as a person and business.

Of course, don’t let perfection paralyze you. But, pay attention to your grammar – because you will be judged by what and how you write.


There are customers who will think less of your brand when they repeatedly come across poor grammar in your copy.

You should pay attention to detail.

On March 6th, 2012, Copyblogger shared the “15 Grammar Goofs That Make You Look Silly,” and it went viral. Content marketers and bloggers learned a lot from it.


Do your best to write correctly. Every word, phrase, and sentence is important – no matter what industry you’re in, good grammar means business.

For example, Colour Works conducted a study of 1,700 online daters and found that 43% of users consider bad grammar decidedly unattractive, while 35% find good grammar to be appealing.

When the error is prominent, bad grammar and spelling mistakes can reduce sales. Over time, it results in reduced trust for a site or marketer.


Conversational writing is the easiest way to write engaging and useful content. Sometimes, it’s okay to choose to break a rule, if it results in copy that flows well and makes sense.

But there are some grammatical errors you should avoid at all costs.

Why would any reasonable writer use “you’re” instead of “your” and “their” instead of “there”?

These are common words used every day. Falling into such mistakes can be unpardonable, especially if your target audience is always looking out for a writing error.

The infographic above can help you avoid some of those spelling and grammatical goofs that would make you look silly and destroy your credibility.

As a final check, have an editor review your copy, like I do, to reduce the likelihood of typos living on your landing page and hurting your credibility.

4. Using Unrealistic Headlines

There’s no doubt that the headline is important. In fact, it’s arguably the most important element of your landing page.

When you look at the perfect landing page, the headline comes first, because it’s the first thing the customer sees.


Why is the headline so important?

Ted Nicholas, a renowned direct response copywriter, said that 73% of buying decisions are made when customers look at the headline. And, Brian Clark asserted that 8 out of 10 people will read your headline.

Given these reasons, you can see why a lot of people write unrealistic or wildly inflated headlines, but headlines like that will kill your credibility.

Instead, write powerful and irresistible headlines that offer enormous value and are based on reality.


Writing click-bait just to lure people into your copy will boomerang negatively. Even if people are attracted by the headline, they likely won’t click on your call-to-action.

If your headline sounds too good to be true, then it probably isn’t true. Avoid such headlines and your copy will be more credible.

Additionally, avoid making unrealistic claims. Here’s an example of a typical headline that makes an unrealistic claim:



If you’re a beginner to lead generation and customer acquisition, progress is usually slow at first. But, with consistency, you can build a high converting landing page that builds your business.

But, like I said earlier, there is no one right – or wrong – approach. There are other credibility killers, but the only way to be certain about what works and what to ignore is to conduct A/B tests.

Which other landing page credibility killers have you eliminated from your landing pages?